The Greatest Mystery in Music
- CF McHale
- May 30
- 3 min read
Why Music Moves Us in Ways Science Can’t Fully Explain
“Music can name the unnameable and communicate the unknowable.”— Leonard Bernstein
Why Does Music Touch Our Emotions So Deeply?
Music is life. It is the invisible river of emotions. It’s an emotional lifeline. It’s a dance across a midnight beach. It’s the heavy night in a 3 am dive bar. Melody can reduce you to tears, ignite joy, or transport you back in time. Harmony can drench you in an emotional tsunami. But why?
We know how music works: sound waves vibrate in the air, your ears receive them, your brain processes them. I took course in music college that gave me all the science. But none of that explains the mystery behind why music affects us so profoundly. This is a question artists and philosophers have been asking for centuries. Do we want the answer? No. We want to drop the needle and get lost.
Dido’s Lament
— The Anatomy of Grief in Music
Purcell’s “Dido’s Lament” is over 300 years old. Yet the sorrow it expresses feels timeless. Even without understanding the words, listeners feel the weight of heartbreak. The key lies in the descending chromatic bass line.
🎧 Recommended Listening:
The music physically falls, and so do we. That’s the power of melodic storytelling—no explanation needed. This is music as emotion, not decoration.
A Love Supreme
— Spiritual Emotion Without Lyrics
John Coltrane’s A Love Supreme is a deeply personal jazz suite, a meditation in sound. There are no lyrics, just repeated motifs. Yet the emotional depth is staggering. When travel I use the music to save tve vibe from the hotel room.
🎧 Suggested Listening:
At 4:55, four notes repeat: “A Love Supreme.” It becomes a mantra. Through tone, repetition, and phrasing, Coltrane transforms a simple melody into a spiritual experience. I close my eyes and float away.
What Science Tells Us (And What It Doesn’t)
Music activates many areas of the brain:
Amygdala: Emotion
Hippocampus: Memory
Auditory Cortex: Sound processing
We can track these responses. But science still can’t tell us why music can make us cry, laugh, or feel awe. This is the true mystery: how organized sound creates universal emotion across time and culture.
The Truth: Music Is the Mystery
“To dissect music to understand why it moves us is like dissecting a bird to learn flight. You might learn something, but it won’t fly again.”— paraphrased from Yo-Yo Ma
Maybe we don’t need the full answer. Maybe the power of music lies in its mystery. Or maybe Yo-Yo Ma shapes the answer in the air with his singing bow.
We return to it not for explanations—but for connection. For healing. For the emotion that lives between the notes.
Share Your Music Mystery
What’s one song, symphony, or sound that’s moved you beyond words? It gets too intense for me sometimes. I’ve sat in concert halls in tears. Drop your story in the comments. Let’s keep unraveling the greatest mystery in music—together.
TL;DR: Why Music Moves Us
Music bypasses logic and goes straight to emotion
Classical and jazz pieces show how melody alone can express grief or spiritual joy
Science tracks brain activity, but doesn’t explain why we feel
The true power of music lies in its mystery
And none of that even comes close to explaining the electric charge of a dropped beat in a rave.
Music is life. That’s all we need to know.
Comments